View Single Post
Old 12-09-2025, 05:10 PM  
2MuchMark
Videochat Solutions
 
2MuchMark's Avatar
 
Industry Role:
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: Canada
Posts: 49,818
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mindi View Post
Now that it's not 6am and I'd haven't been coding for 18 hours straight, let me address this one

You're confusing scraping with licensed API use. They're not the same thing - legally, technically, or strategically.

Let me break this down since you brought up "scraping or stealing":

SCRAPING vs. LICENSED APIs

Scraping (what you're describing):

❌ Unauthorized copying of copyrighted content
❌ Violates terms of service
❌ Gets you cease & desist letters
❌ Sites detect it and block your IPs
❌ Data goes stale, breaks when site structure changes
❌ Legal liability

Licensed API Use (what I'm doing):

✅ Yelp Fusion API - Official commercial license
✅ Google Places API - Official commercial license
✅ TripAdvisor Content API - Official commercial license
✅ Legal terms of service explicitly grant you rights to display content
✅ Proper attribution required (which protects you)
✅ Data refreshes automatically
✅ No legal risk

The difference:

When you scrape TripAdvisor's website, you're copying copyrighted content without permission. Reviews, photos, descriptions - all copyrighted.

When you use TripAdvisor's Content API, they GIVE YOU A LICENSE to display that content as long as you follow display requirements (attribution, linking back, etc.).

Same data. Completely different legal status.

WHY THIS MATTERS:
1. Scalability

Scraping breaks constantly (site redesigns, anti-bot measures, IP blocks)
APIs are stable, documented, supported
I can deploy 50 cities without worrying about getting shut down

2. Legal Protection

API terms of service = you have a license
Scraping = you're violating copyright and TOS
I sleep fine. Scrapers get sued.

3. Data Quality

APIs provide structured, clean data
Scraping gives you messy HTML you have to parse
My system pulls 500+ listings in minutes with zero errors

4. Business Legitimacy

APIs = you're a legitimate platform partner
Scraping = you're a parasite hoping not to get caught
When I talk to businesses about premium listings, I'm not hiding what I do


THE TECHNICAL REALITY:

What my system does:
1. Yelp Fusion API call → Returns JSON with:
- Business name, address, phone, hours
- Star rating (4.5 stars, 238 reviews)
- Review excerpts with attribution
- Photos with license to display
- All structured, clean, ready to use

2. Google Places API call → Returns JSON with:
- Additional business data
- More photos
- Google Maps integration
- Place IDs for linking

3. AI Processing:
- Generate unique descriptions (not copied from anywhere)
- Create 8-10 SEO-optimized articles
- Build bilingual content (EN/IT, EN/FR, etc.)
- Optimize meta tags, schema markup, internal linking

4. WordPress deployment:
- Automated posting via WP-CLI
- Custom post types for listings
- Taxonomy management
- Image optimization
- Mobile-responsive theme

Result: Complete directory in under 24 hours
This isn't "a couple lines of code to scrape WordPress API."
This is 16,000+ lines of Python across 34 modules handling:

API authentication and rate limiting
Data normalization across multiple sources
Bilingual content generation
SEO optimization
Image processing
Database management
WordPress integration
Error handling and logging


THE BUSINESS MODEL:

This isn't an AdSense arbitrage play.

Here's how it actually works:

Build directory (MontrealInsider.com, TylerInsider.com, etc.)
Rank for local searches ("best restaurants in Brantford," "things to do in Tyler")
Capture business owner attention (they Google themselves, find my listing)
Convert to SEO audits, custom software sales, consulting, other things that I do
Upsell implementation (ongoing SEO services)

The directory is the lead magnet, not the revenue.
I'm not trying to compete with Yelp on ad revenue. I'm using owned traffic assets to generate leads for my core business: SEO and custom software

Proven results:

Built MontrealInsider.com as a demo
Generated multiple inbound leads within 48 hours
Directories consistently convert at 2-3% to paid audits, SEO services, custom software


WHY "EVERYONE DOING THIS" DOESN'T MATTER:

Most people doing "local directories" are:

Running AdSense farms (low margins, Google penalizes them)
Actually scraping (illegal, get shut down)
Building manually (takes weeks per city, doesn't scale)
Not monetizing properly (just hoping for ad clicks)
Have no backend service (no real business, just hoping to flip the site)

I'm doing this differently:

Legal API usage (can scale to 100+ cities without legal risk)
Automated deployment (24 hours per directory)
Real backend business (SEO services with proven demand)
Asset building (own the traffic, own the customer relationship)


THE "LATE TO THE PARTY" ARGUMENT:

You're right - APIs have existed for 15 years.

Here's what changed:

AI content generation (ChatGPT/Claude) made it economically viable to create unique, quality content at scale
API pricing dropped (Yelp/Google made APIs more accessible)
Local SEO got easier (Google prioritizes helpful local content)
WordPress optimization tools (deployment is faster than ever)

But mainly:

I'm not trying to invent something new. I'm applying 25+ years of affiliate marketing experience (multiple 7 figures properties in adult industry) to a proven model.

The "magic" isn't the technology - it's the execution:

Speed of deployment (most people take weeks, I take hours)
Business model integration (directory → leads → service revenue)
Legal compliance (APIs not scraping)
Scalability (can deploy 50+ cities)


BOTTOM LINE:

If you think this is "just scraping with WordPress API" - you're missing the entire point.

This is:

Legal API licensing (not scraping)
Automated content generation (not copying)
Lead generation (not AdSense arbitrage)
Real business backend (not hoping to flip domains)

If it's so easy, why aren't you doing it?

I'm not here to convince skeptics. I'm here to build assets and generate leads.

The proof is in the results: I'm getting inbound business inquiries from live demos while everyone else is debating whether it's "rocket science."

Good luck with whatever you're working on.


For business inquires, my website is WebIgniter.com

So first, that is a copy-paste from Claude, an AI, something you blasted Legacy for doing just the other day.

Next, you said:

"These rank very well because I've been doing SEO since 1997".
- Source: Post #1

"So many top 5's. Out of 764 keywords, 150 are ranked top 10 in google"
- Source: post #22

"It outranks Trip Advisor for many local searches"
- Source: Post #26

Except that it doesn't. See for yourself:

https://www.google.com/search?q=best...s+in+brantford
https://www.google.com/search?q=top+...ntford+ontario
https://www.google.com/search?q=wher...t+in+brantford

So which is it - SEO ranking success or just a demo site for lead generation?
__________________

Custom Coding | Videochat Solutions | Age Verification | IT Help & Support
www.2Much.net
2MuchMark is offline   Share thread on Digg Share thread on Twitter Share thread on Reddit Share thread on Facebook Reply With Quote