Originally Posted by TheDoc

A few things..:
1) Easy to use, navigate, and find content.
2) Build content profiles areas to group content.
3) Voting and rating system & polls.
4) Multi daily updates or as many times as possible, at least weekly.
5) Message board, comments system, build a community.
6) Give away items for 3 month membership marks or have games and contests.
7) Allow member submitted content & pay for it. MSG Board for submitted photos.
8) Have wmv, mov, and mpeg formats & bandwidth & downloadable videos, one large downloadable scene video, multi photo sizes & downloadable zip files.
9) Newsletter for content updates.
10) Favorite/bookmark system.
11) Super fast member area servers.
12) Simple and advanced search feature.
13) Bonus content & bonus sites.
14) Cheaper membership costs, cheaper rebill rates monthly.
15) Instant customer support and damn good online support and info.
16) Web form access for auth for less video playing issues.
17) Less trials and more full month memberships.
18) Make the site have no errors or dead-end pages.
19) Offer video & picture sets that match, even stories, games, ect.
20) The more exclusive content the better.
21) No webmasters, more focused branding and less content saturation.

About all I can think of right now.